top of page
Lisa - Refire Fitness

Why the ‘All or Nothing’ Mindset is Killing Your Motivation

Here’s a scenario for you: It’s January 3rd. You’ve been eating perfectly all week—grilled chicken, salads, a heroic effort to avoid the leftover Christmas cookies. Then, tragedy strikes. You eat a cookie.

What happens next? If you’re like most people, the guilt kicks in, followed closely by an internal meltdown: “Welp, I ruined it. May as well order a pizza and start again on Monday.”

Sound familiar? This, my friends, is the All or Nothing mindset. And let me tell you, it’s the silent killer of fitness and wellness goals everywhere. Here’s the truth: you didn’t ruin anything by eating a cookie. You’re not a failure, and you don’t need to throw away the entire week. One moment doesn’t undo progress. What actually stops progress is quitting every time you’re less than perfect.

The science backs this up: building habits is about consistency, not perfection. According to research, missing a day or having a misstep doesn’t “erase” progress—it’s how quickly you recover that matters.

And here’s where the January Fire Starter Calendar comes in for ya! It gives you one simple action per day that you can show up for, no matter how “off-track” you feel.

Missed yesterday’s task? Who cares. Start today. Had a bad meal? Cool. Your next one doesn’t have to be. Progress isn’t a straight line—it’s more like a squiggle drawn by a toddler, and that’s okay. The point is to keep going.


Here’s a quick mindset shift for you: Instead of “I have to start over,” try “I’m just picking up where I left off.” Because one cookie (or skipped workout, or lazy day) doesn’t define you. How you respond next does.

So let’s ditch the all-or-nothing thinking, okay? Perfect is overrated, and consistency is what gets results. Use the Fire Starter Calendar as a daily nudge to show up imperfectly—and still make progress. Because progress > perfection, every. single. time.

 

If you liked this read, check out this one about overcoming failure!

Want one on one coaching? Reach out today!


 

Refire Fitness is active on social media and aims to provide an engaging community with education on fitness, nutrition and mental health. Join me on Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest!

2 views

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page